I think that there should be a grid made of various attributes that make a nation libertarian or un-libertarian. The other set of possible values would be the various nations.
May be smaller countries are better options for freedom than monarchs or one religion states. And what the hell am I suppose to do with economic freedom if I constantly fear persecution.
The Muslims seem pretty happy with it. In fact, every year millions of them voluntarily emigrate to the place. I don’t hear the Amish complaining about how they can’t wear bright colors or miniskirts either.
Huh? I would like to see a source for those “millions”. I’d very suprised if Saudi Arabia recieves a significant amount of immigration. Or are you referring to the “guest workers” that go there because the local Saudi youth can’t be arsed to do lowly jobs like streetsweeping?
So in addition to the haj, Saudi Arabia also receives hundreds of thousands of workers who go there to earn money for their families rather than starve back home. Good for the Saudis.
The fact that workers would go to Saudia Arabia for work, even though its “modern day slavery”, displays the fact that they prefer the potential for work in Saudia Arabia, than the conditions they face where they were originally. There is no need to bring up the argumentum ad misericordiam that “modern day slavery” is.
Re-read the article and you will see that the workers are deceived about the work, they are not free to leave after they find out and they are threatened with violence. That is slavery.
I’m very impressed by your witty insults and superiour knowledge of the world. That said, I associate something ,you know, more permanent with the word “emigrate” than a pilgrimage.
And I also doubt most pilgrims give a rat’s ass about the internal politics of Saudi Arabia unless they run afoul of the religious police or something.
The millions of devout Muslims who go to Saudi Arabia voluntarily don’t seem to have a problem with religious police. You need to mind your own effing business.
I think it could be interesting to make some reflections not only about the “official” libertarian level established by rules and laws of one nation, but also about the “unofficial” libertarian level based on real actions of one nation’ people. Here in Italy, for example, there’s a suffocating system of public institutions with all their bureaucracies and rules and an high level of all kind of taxes, but a lot of people simply try to ignore them and act in their own interest.