Self-defence is threft

[Torsten]

@Anonymous Coward

If it were a voluntary association why did they attack when we delivered up the Declaration of Independence to them?

They were defending their “rights”!

[E_R_Olovetto]

@libertarian

Many anarcho-capitalists justify the American revolution.

The British attacked the US because we didn’t obey to their government.
Therefore, we made the British kill many things in the war.
Determinists would agree.

If we had a voluntary contractual association, and an individual in the association decided to not obey to the association, the association would and have the obligation attack the individual. But the individual would defend to the attack. The individual defending would be considered morally wrong by many anarchists. Correct? If Great Britain was a voluntary assocation, we should not fight back; but we did fought back. Therefore, fighting back or resisting the British is equivalent to threft from the British government.

Are we responsible for fighting back a voluntary association because we first breached the contract?