The legitimate samaritan state?

[nirgrahamUK]

theres been a lot of debate recently on the subject ‘perilous situations’, though it was framed a different way:

Re: Brainpolice's statements in "You are free to leave..."

Brainpolice said: For example, one’s ownership over their home, even if it is a just case of ownership, does not give you the right to assault and murder people just because they are in one’s home. In other words, property rights do not trump life and liberty. That strikes me as odd. I thought… well, I remember reading two very poignant scenarios in which consistency in justice must prevail over liberal morality if consistency is to be maintained. One example was that a man who has been lost …