A property rights violation occurs when one individual damages the person or property of another individual. In the above scenario if no one is infected with H1N1 due to the actions of whoever is carrying the virus then they have not violated anyone else’s property rights. If the infected person transfers the virus to someone else then they have violated that persons property rights. A persons intentions has no bearing on rather or not a property rights violation has occurred. Intentions only come into play when considering what punishment and or reparations the concerned parties deem appropriate.