Difference of opinion between Mises.org forum members

I would like to make something like a survey for all of you, regarding certain issues that we’re not in complete agreement with. The idea is to make a short answer for each item (preferably, a ‘yes’ or ‘no’, as you agree or disagree). Here’s my try:

  • Anarchism: Yes
  • Praxeology: Yes
  • Natural rights: No
  • ABCT: Yes
  • Corporations: No
  • Death penalty: No (not definitive)
  • Abortion: Yes (not definitive)
  • Democracy: No
  • Objectivism: No
  • Psycological egoism: Yes
  • Ethical egoism: Yes
  • 100% FRB: Yes
  • Slave contracts: No

Well, that’s what I got so far.

  • Anarchism: Yes
  • Praxeology: Yes
  • Natural rights: Yes; separated from a belief in God, no
  • ABCT: Yes
  • Corporations: Yes
  • Death penalty: Yes
  • Abortion: No
  • Democracy: No
  • Objectivism: No
  • Psycological egoism: No
  • Ethical egoism: No
  • 100% FRB: Yes
  • Religion: Roman Catholic

That’s mine. Can you explain the ‘no’ on the death penalty?

  • Anarchism: Don’t care, don’t believe it will ever happen
  • Praxeology: Yes
  • Natural Rights: Only defined with respect to a Creator
  • ABCT: Yes
  • Corporations: Yes
  • Death Penalty: No Definitive Opinion
  • Abortion: No
  • Democracy: Modern democracy: no; democracy as defined in Pericles’ funeral oration: yes
  • Objectivism: No
  • Psycological Egoism: no
  • Religion: Yes
  • 100% FRB: No Definitive Opinion

This should be fun [:P]

  • Anarchism: Yes
  • Praxeology: Yes
  • Natural rights: Yes
  • ABCT: Yes
  • Corporations: No (the corporate form can be probably be replicated in a freed market, but current corporations: no)
  • Death penalty: No
  • Abortion: Yes
  • Democracy: Yes (in the sense of participatory democracy defended by the New Left, Rothbard, and Plauche)
  • Objectivism: No (well, I guess I’m a post-Objectivist/neo-Aristotelian, but definitely not an orthodox Randroid)
  • Psycological egoism: Either a truism or wrong, IMO
  • Ethical egoism: Kind of (eudaimonist)
  • 100% FRB: Yes
  • Anarchism: Yes
  • Praxeology: Yes
  • Natural rights: Yes (though not the Rothbardian rationalist conception)
  • ABCT: Yes
  • Corporations: What does this mean?
  • Death penalty: Yes
  • Abortion: Yes
  • Democracy: No
  • Objectivism: No
  • Psychological egoism: What does this mean?
  • Ethical egoism: No
  • 100% FRB: I know what FRB stands for, but not what the 100% means.

what about ‘corporations’ ? yes no what ?

FYI, I use N/A to specify areas where I do not feel qualified to say whether I agree with it fully or not. It would help if the list included definitions to base one’s Yes or No on.

  • Anarchism: Yes. (Panarchism as consolation, if Anarchism doesn’t occur in my lifetime).
  • Praxeology: Undecided
  • Natural rights: Undecided (leaning ‘No’)
  • ABCT: N/A
  • Corporations: Yes (In favor of market alternatives to statist-corptocracy)
  • Death penalty: Maybe (self-defense may unavoidably result in the death of an aggressor, etc.)
  • Abortion: Indifferent
  • Democracy: No
  • Objectivism: No, on the whole (This & Post-Objectivism have proven educational, though)
  • Psycological egoism: Undecided
  • Ethical egoism: Undecided
  • 100% FRB: Undecided (I would prefer competing banking systems)
  • Irreligion: Ignostic
  • Anarchism: Undecided
  • Praxeology: Yes
  • Natural rights: NA
  • ABCT: Yes
  • Corporations: Yes (if not state backed)
  • Death penalty: No (due to state enforcement)
  • Abortion: No
  • Democracy: No
  • Objectivism: No
  • Psycological egoism: NA
  • Ethical egoism: No
  • 100% FRB: Yes (shouldn’t this be 100% reserve banking?)
  • Anarchism: Yes
  • Praxeology: Yes
  • Natural rights: No
  • ABCT: Yes
  • Corporations: No
  • Death penalty: Yes (Dependent on each individuals property laws)
  • Abortion: Yes (not definitive)
  • Democracy: No
  • Objectivism: No
  • Psycological egoism: Yes
  • Ethical egoism: Yes
  • 100% FRB: No (I disagree with bank regulation. I will personally choose a 100% Reserve Bank.)

Okay, here’s my list:

  • Anarchism: Yes
  • Praxeology: Yes
  • Natural rights: Yes
  • ABCT: Yes
  • Corporations: No
  • Death penalty: No
  • Abortion: No
  • Democracy: No
  • Objectivism: Yes
  • Psycological egoism: No
  • Ethical egoism: Yes
  • 100% FRB: No
  • Anarchism: Yes
  • Praxeology: Yes
  • Natural rights: No
  • ABCT: Yes
  • Corporations: No
  • Death penalty: No
  • Abortion: No
  • Democracy: No
  • Objectivism: No
  • Psycological egoism: Yes
  • Ethical egoism: No
  • 100% FRB: Yes
  • Anarchism: Yes
  • Praxeology: Yes
  • Natural rights: Yes
  • ABCT: Yes
  • Corporations: ??
  • Death penalty: probably not
  • Abortion: Yes
  • Democracy: No
  • Objectivism: No
  • Psycological egoism: Yes (?)
  • Ethical egoism: Yes (?)
  • 100% FRB: full reserve banking ? yes
  • religion : agnostic
  • slave contracts : no

I know that the idea of answering ‘yes’ or ‘no’ or something short is not the best (one can agree the ABCT explained by X, but not the Y interpretation, or one can favor corporations, but on certain industries/cases, etc), but the idea is to have an approach of the member’s opinions, and not writing an article for each of the points (in fact, each point is and certainly was discussed in other threads).

For “corporations” what I mean is if you like the corporation concept, as an independent entity and separated from its members.

For 100% FRB I mean 100% fractional reserve backing (or full reserve banking, or whatever you want to call it), such as Rothbard, Block and Hoppe are for. I didn’t ask for free-banking because I think everyone here is for free-banking.

My death penalty answer is No, but is not definitive. Maybe I’m not for death penalty as a state-backed policy, but don’t know how the free market would handle it.

Let’s continue! :stuck_out_tongue:

Okay, that was confusing because I thought it might mean, “all FRB, all the time.” “100% fractional” seems a contradiction in terms. I’d suggest changing the OP to “100% reserve banking”, or “FRB is fraud”

so called slave contracts ? : no.

Heres my take

  • Anarchism: Yes
  • Praxeology: Yes
  • Natural rights: No
  • ABCT: Yes
  • Corporations: No
  • Death penalty: Yes
  • Abortion: Yes
  • Democracy: No
  • Objectivism: No
  • Psycological egoism: Yes
  • Ethical egoism: Yes
  • 100% FRB: Free currency, FRB may exist

nice topic

  • Anarchism: yes
  • Praxeology: yes
  • Natural rights: yes
  • ABCT: yes
  • Corporations: yes
  • Death penalty: don’t oppose in principle, oppose the socialist criminal justice system
  • Abortion: yes
  • Democracy: No
  • Objectivism: yes, i don’t think its harmful
  • Psycological egoism: no
  • Ethical egoism: no
  • 100% FRB: ya
  • Anarchism: Yes
  • Praxeology: Yes
  • Natural rights: No
  • ABCT: Yes
  • Corporations: Yes
  • Death penalty: Don’t care
  • Abortion: Don’t care
  • Democracy: No
  • Objectivism: No
  • Psycological egoism: Yes
  • Ethical egoism: No
  • 100% FRB: Yes
  • Anarchism: Yes
  • Praxeology: Yes
  • Natural rights: Yes
  • ABCT: Yes
  • Corporations: Yes
  • Death penalty: No
  • Abortion: Yes
  • Democracy: No
  • Objectivism: small-o
  • Psycological egoism: Mostly
  • Ethical egoism: Mostly
  • 100% FRB: No
  • Voluntaryism: Yes
  • Coercion: No