He’s a fool.
Oh, come on. He is the greatest master of all (skeptical) ‘philosophers’ and the prince of positivism. And zefreak is one of his pages.
So if I cut off my finger it means that my finger was not part of my hand? [:O]
These christian occultists sure have funny ways of thinking about things.
Of course it was part of your hand, but “Was” is in the past tense for a reason. Furthermore, I do not see how this is relevant to any point hitherto.
Many more do not understand the arguments that they argue against, and have a cute tendency to reply to it despite their ignorance.