Except that you can count on the fact that there is “method to the madness”.
The way I organised my shelf was, my favorites / the best at eye level… and the less so near the bottom. Classics to most recent. Non fiction and fiction separated. So it’s multi layered, but natural and makes sense… i.e chronological order.
Top shelf
Classics (Plato, Aristotle, Dante, Socrates, Machiavelli) so philosophy mostly —> leads into History of Economic Thought, then Fed and Anti-Fed papers, the law, Human Action, MES → study guides, America’s Great Depression, Economics in One Lesson, (etc), then Political thought, Egalitarianism revolt against nature, many other libertarian / Austrian books…
Second from the top
Two deep.
Back - Classical literature: Tolstoy, MacBeth etc.
Front - Dystopia’s, Liberty orientated (Moon is harsh mistress, Atlas Shrugged, Johnathan livingston Seagull, catch 22, This Perfect Hell, Walden) .. space divider for future growth), then some continuation from the end of the above top shelf, focusing on politics (common sense, revolution: a manifesto, constitution of liberty, for a new liberty, how i found freedom in an unfree world etc.)
Second from the bottom
History (War section mostly from the left, Sun Tzu, A War in Words, Imperial Hubris, first hand counts etc, then it goes into Australian section history, gold mining, settlers, founders → more broader history (Alexander the great, general history book, then Illiad, The Odyssey)
Bottom shelf
More on Australian politics, then Fiction (Robert Ludlum, Matthew Reilly etc)
Basically, I catered to my environment… Best spot for the eyes, best books go there. Easiest access spot, best books go there. Then in chronological order, but what the book is discussing really. And if it’s timeless, then when it was written..