Hoppe's Theory of Argumentation

Here is Jevon’s ‘computer’, as promised. (Such a system could be expanded for any amount of characters, beyond those of the alphabet.)

http://s000.tinyupload.com/?file_id=59623178074715379202

thanks. downloaded and saved.

I don’t know when I’ll get to it as I’m reading Mises “Socialism” along side Cohen’s “Intro. to Logic” presently, but in due time.

[:)]

Ah, here is Wicksteed (with a 105 years precedent, apparently):

“But Jevons fully and clearly recognised the mechanical nature of the process,

and consequently perfected its mechanism. By an odd linguistic error he called

his logic machine a " logical" machine, as though the machine itself were logical

and could reason ; but, as a matter of fact, he showed with the most perfect cogency

that whereas the formulation of the premisses is the all-important process, and is

in no sense mechanical, yet when once they are formulated they can be manipulated

mechanically, and all their implications rendered explicit without chance of error or omission,

if the mechanism is rendered perfect. If it is not, the process will be no less mechanical

but will be more liable to error. It will be worked by bad mechanics, but still by mechanics”

(Wicksteed 1905:433).

Wicksteed, Philip. September 1905. Jevons’ Economic Work. Economic Journal 15(59):432-436.